Chapter 5

What Could Not Be Sold

In a street in Kashi, a king sells his wife and son — and then sells himself, to a master he could never bring himself to accept

Kashi

The month was running out, and there was still no way to pay the fee. The three of them reached Kashi — Shaivya, Rohitashva, and the king who had once ruled Ayodhya.

Vishvamitra arrived and began demanding his account. The deadline was almost up. In the Devi Bhagavata the sage gives him only a quarter of a day. There was no way the money was going to appear.

Shaivya's request

In the Devi Bhagavata, Shaivya then said: sell me.

Not once, but again and again. Harishchandra refused. But in the end he agreed. "I will do," he said, "what even the most heartless of men would not dare to do."

The story itself is uneasy with this moment. It does not make it easy.

In the market

In the Devi Bhagavata the king stands his wife in the street and calls out: "Does anyone need a maidservant? This woman is dearer to me than my own life."

An old brahmin bought her. In the Devi Bhagavata this brahmin is Vishvamitra himself, in another form.

In the Devi Bhagavata, Rohitashva will not let go of his mother's cloth. He stumbles at every step, falls, then gets up and clings to it again. The brahmin beat him, but the boy kept walking with his mother, crying. So the brahmin bought him too.

But the money still fell short. Vishvamitra came for the fee and demanded the full amount.

The king's turn

Harishchandra called out: will anyone buy me? But it had to be before sunset.

An outcaste came forward, whom the Markandeya Purana names Pravira. Dharma himself had come in that form — but Harishchandra did not know it.

The king refused. He was a kshatriya, and becoming the servant of an outcaste felt, in his own eyes, like the lowest fall he could take. In the Devi Bhagavata he says that the dharma appropriate to the highest is one thing, that of the middling another, and that assigned to the lowest is degrading to the mind.

Then Vishvamitra stepped forward, and threatened him with a curse. The king panicked, and said: I will become your servant myself. Vishvamitra promptly sold him to that same outcaste, and collected the fee.

Harishchandra was now that outcaste's slave.

Note: The sale in Kashi is in the Markandeya Purana (chapter 8) and the Devi Bhagavata (7.22–23). In the Markandeya, an "old brahmin" buys the wife and son, and after selling himself Harishchandra becomes the servant of the outcaste Pravira, in whose form Dharma has come. In the Devi Bhagavata 7.22, the old brahmin who buys the wife and son is named as Kaushika — that is, Vishvamitra in a changed form — and Harishchandra first refuses the outcaste. But further on, in 7.27, Dharma says at the end that he himself was that outcaste, that brahmin, and that serpent too. Both statements stand in the text; this site records that internal tension rather than removing one to make it fit the other. This story rests on the sale of a wife and on becoming an outcaste's servant; the text itself is uneasy with both of these episodes, and they are kept just as uneasy here. The story treats the outcaste's caste status as "the lowest rung", but that is not a claim about anyone's natural or rightful standing — and by the end that same outcaste turns out to be Dharma himself. The sums involved differ between the two texts and are not given here. The English lines are a natural retelling of the Sanskrit, not a word-for-word translation.

Source: from the Aitareya Brahmana, the Markandeya Purana and the Devi Bhagavata, What Could Not Be Sold

Now — how much stayed with you?

Who said it?

"Does anyone need a maidservant? This woman is dearer to me than my own life." — who said this?

  • Shaivya
  • Vishvamitra
  • Harishchandra
  • The outcaste
Read the whole story — A call no king should have to make

According to the Devi Bhagavata, Harishchandra stood his wife in the street and called out to sell her.

His words were that this woman was dearer to him than his own life.

He had refused at first; it was Shaivya who had asked him, again and again, to do exactly this.

What happened?

According to the Devi Bhagavata, who persuaded Harishchandra to sell his wife?

  • Shaivya herself, by asking again and again
  • Vishvamitra
  • The outcaste
  • Narada
Read the whole story — A wife's insistence

Shaivya said, more than once, that she should be sold to pay off the fee.

Harishchandra refused for a long time.

In the end he said he would do what even the most heartless people would not do.

Why is that?

How does the story treat the moment of selling Shaivya?

  • As a moment of pride
  • As an ordinary transaction
  • It does not mention it at all
  • As an uneasy moment
Read the whole story — What was not easy

Harishchandra calls this moment something even heartless people would not do.

The story neither glorifies it nor lets it pass unremarked.

This is why this chapter has not softened it either.

What happened?

What did Rohitashva do while being sold?

  • He stood quietly
  • He clung to his mother's cloth, crying, and kept walking with her
  • He went back to the king
  • He ran away
Read the whole story — The boy who would not let go

In the Devi Bhagavata the child stumbles at every step, but does not let go of his mother's cloth.

The brahmin beats him, but he keeps walking, crying.

This is what leads the brahmin to buy the boy as well.

The texts disagree

In the Devi Bhagavata, who is the old brahmin who buys Shaivya and Rohitashva?

  • Vishvamitra, in a changed form
  • Indra himself
  • Narada
  • Vasishtha
Read the whole story — Who bought them

In the Markandeya Purana, the buyer is only "an old brahmin".

In the Devi Bhagavata, that old brahmin is Vishvamitra himself, in a changed form.

So in chapter 7.22, Vishvamitra both sets the test and appears as the buyer; chapter 7.27 later complicates this by having Dharma claim that same brahmin identity too.

Who am I?

I came to Kashi in the form of an outcaste. I buy Harishchandra, but I am really Dharma himself. In the Markandeya Purana people know me by the name Pravira. Who am I?

  • Narada
  • Varuna
  • A messenger of Yama
  • Dharma, in the guise of an outcaste
Read the whole story — Who was behind the name

The outcaste who buys Harishchandra in Kashi is named Pravira in the Markandeya Purana.

By the end of the story it becomes clear that behind that form was Dharma himself.

But Harishchandra did not know this at the time.

What happened?

Why did Harishchandra refuse the outcaste before being sold to him?

  • Because too low a price was offered
  • Because he was a kshatriya, and serving an outcaste felt, in his own eyes, like the greatest fall he could take
  • Because he had recognised him
  • Because he did not want to be sold at all
Read the whole story — The king's own mind

In the Devi Bhagavata, Harishchandra first refuses the outcaste.

He was a kshatriya, and in the social order of that time this felt to him like the lowest he could fall.

The story shows this thinking of his; it does not justify it — because that same outcaste turns out to be Dharma himself.

What happened?

After refusing the outcaste, whom did Harishchandra hand himself over to?

  • Shaivya
  • The brahmin
  • Vishvamitra
  • Indra
Read the whole story — Out of fear of a curse

Vishvamitra came demanding the fee, and threatened him with a curse.

Harishchandra said: I will become your servant myself.

Vishvamitra sold him to that same outcaste he had earlier refused.

Put it in order

Put the sales that took place in Kashi in order.

  • Harishchandra selling himself → Shaivya and Rohitashva being sold → sale to the outcaste
  • The outcaste's bid → Shaivya being sold → Rohitashva being sold → Harishchandra being sold
  • Rohitashva being sold → Shaivya being sold → Harishchandra being sold
  • Shaivya being sold → Rohitashva being sold with her → Harishchandra being sold to the outcaste
Read the whole story — One after another

First the wife was sold, then the son along with her.

But the fee was still not fully paid.

In the end the king was sold himself, to the outcaste.

Riddle

I am the city where the hardest part of this story unfolds — a family sold in the marketplace, and a king serving at a cremation ground. I am called the city of ghats. Who am I?

  • Kashi
  • Ujjain
  • Mathura
  • Prayag
Read the whole story — Where it all happens

Harishchandra and his family were sold as soon as they reached Kashi.

At its cremation ground the king had to serve the outcaste.

A ghat in Varanasi is still called Harishchandra Ghat today.