Kanda 7

Uttara Kanda

The story was over, and still one book remained

Ravana's story

Rama was crowned on returning to Ayodhya, and the time began that is called Ramarajya.

But before it goes forward, the Uttara Kanda turns back.

The sage Agastya sits Rama down and tells him the whole story of Ravana — the story nobody had asked for during the war.

Ravana's ancestry was not entirely rakshasa.

On his father's side, he descended from the sage Pulastya, a son of Brahma.

And Lanka had not been his to begin with. It belonged to his half-brother Kubera.

Ravana performed severe austerities and won a boon from Brahma — that no god, gandharva, yaksha or demon should be able to kill him.

Every kind of being he thought might be a danger to him, he listed one by one.

One kind he did not list at all.

Human beings.

They seemed to him so insignificant that he did not think them worth counting.

After receiving the boon he defeated Kubera in war and took Lanka from him.

The Pushpaka Vimana came into his hands in that same defeat — the very vimana that years later carried Rama back to Ayodhya.

And that one omission, made while asking for the boon, became in the end the road to his death.

The story of Hanuman's childhood comes in this part as well.

As a child Hanuman once saw the sun in the sky, took it for a fruit, and leapt to catch it.

And that was not his only piece of mischief. He would get into the hermitages of sages and scatter their belongings, overturn the things of worship, throw the materials of the sacrifice about.

The sages were troubled.

But they also knew that with the boons of Brahma and Indra this child was invincible, and that there was neither need nor way to punish him heavily.

So they laid a small curse on him — Hanuman would not remember his own strength. Only when someone reminded him would he remember.

On the seashore, Jambavan did exactly that.

What a washerman said

Years passed.

The king's informers lived in every town. Their work was just this — to go from lane to lane listening to what people were saying about the king, and to come back and report it.

One day what they reported was not good.

There was talk in the city that the queen had lived so long in Lanka and the king had taken her back.

And in that talk there was also this: that a washerman, quarrelling with his wife, had said he was no Rama, to take back into his house a woman who had lived in another man's.

Rama asked whether this was only one man's opinion.

The answer was no.

In Lanka he had said that he wanted the answer to be given in front of everyone.

Now that same "everyone" was speaking again.

And this time there was no fire in the middle of it.

Rama decided to send the pregnant Sita away to the forest.

As a king, Rama placed the voice of his people above his own household.

But as a husband, he was not the one who paid the price. Sita did.

The task was given to Lakshmana.

He seated her in a chariot and took her away. He said nothing the whole way.

Sita believed she was going to visit some hermitage.

Only after setting her down across the Ganga did Lakshmana tell her the truth.

And then he took the chariot and went back.

Sita was left standing there.

At Valmiki's hermitage

Sita found shelter at the hermitage of the sage Valmiki.

Lava and Kusha were born there, and grew up there.

Valmiki was the sage who composed the poem we know as the Ramayana.

He made the two boys learn that whole poem by heart, and both learned to sing it — without knowing whose story they were singing.

Meanwhile another thing happened in Ayodhya, which is counted among the hardest episodes in this book.

A brahmin came to the court carrying the body of his son. His claim was that something was going wrong in the kingdom, and that this was why it had happened.

Rama was told that a man named Shambuka was performing austerities, and that by the rules of his varna he had no right to do so.

Rama sought Shambuka out and killed him.

This episode has been sharply criticised for centuries, and still is.

Many scholars consider it part of the later layer of the Uttara Kanda.

But it is present in the text that has come down to us — which is why it has not been hidden here.

Lava and Kusha

Years later an Ashvamedha sacrifice was held in Ayodhya.

Rama had not married again.

He had a golden image of Sita made for the sacrifice, and kept that beside him.

At that sacrifice two boys came and began to sing that poem before the whole assembly.

They went on singing. One canto after another, and then a third.

The assembly listened, and as it listened it grew quieter and quieter.

What was being sung was their own story.

Ayodhya, the exile, the abduction, the sea, Lanka — everything the people sitting in that assembly had lived through was being sung back to them, bound into verse.

And the singers were two boys nobody knew.

Rama was listening to his own life in somebody else's voice.

And then he saw their faces.

Their ages matched.

Their faces did too.

Rama understood. They were his sons.

Into the earth

Sita was called.

Rama said she should take an oath of her purity once, in front of everyone, and after that everything would be well.

Sita came.

She took the oath.

And then she refused to return.

She called on the earth — if I have never thought of anyone but Rama, then let mother earth take me into herself.

The earth opened.

A throne rose up, and on it sat the earth herself.

She took Sita into her lap.

And the two of them went down.

The earth closed again.

Rama was left standing there.

This was the man who had had a bridge built across the sea, who had killed Ravana, and who had served out a fourteen-year exile without a word of complaint.

This time he had no weapon in his hands, and there was no enemy in front of him.

The story ends here — not with a victory, but with an emptiness.

Note: Ravana's earlier history, the curse on Hanuman (sarga 36 — the title of the sarga is itself "The sages curse Hanuman"), Sita's banishment, the killing of Shambuka, Lava and Kusha, the golden image (sarga 91, in Rama's own words) and Sita entering the earth are all in Valmiki's Uttara Kanda. But the Uttara Kanda is precisely the book that many modern scholars, along with the Bala Kanda, consider a later layer, and that argument is still going on. Which means the right thing to say about everything in this book is: it is in the received Valmiki text, in the book whose antiquity is disputed. The informer Bhadra reports the talk that had spread through the whole city (sargas 42–43); the washerman's remark is one example within that, not the sole cause. And the sages made the curse a small one deliberately, because against the boons of Brahma and Indra a greater punishment was neither necessary nor possible.

Source: Valmiki Ramayana, Uttara Kanda

Now — how much stayed with you?

Who am I?

I am the poet who composed this story — and then the people in it came to live at my own hermitage. Who am I?

  • Vyasa
  • Agastya
  • Vasishtha
  • Valmiki
Read the whole story — A story inside its own story

The most extraordinary thing about the Ramayana is that its author is a character in it.

Valmiki does not only write the story — he gives Sita shelter, raises Lava and Kusha, teaches them the story, and finally stands up in Rama's assembly to vouch for Sita's truth.

So the story being told is written by the man standing at the end of it.

This is why the Ramayana is called the adikavya — the first poem, and one that holds its own maker inside it.

Riddle

There were two of us. We sang, in open assembly, the story we were in — and the king sitting in front of us turned out to be our father. Who are we?

  • Nala and Nila
  • Lava and Kusha
  • Khara and Dushana
  • Vali and Sugriva
Read the whole story — Two boys, singing

Lava and Kusha grew up in the hermitage, and did not know whose sons they were.

Valmiki had taught them the whole Ramayana by heart — twenty-four thousand verses, to be sung with the vina.

At the horse sacrifice they sat among the sages and began to sing. The assembly could not stop listening. Rama offered them gold, and they refused it — what use is gold to people who live in a hermitage.

Rama's suspicion began when he saw that the two boys looked exactly like him. Then he sent word to Valmiki.

Fact

Where did Sita finally go, in the Uttara Kanda?

  • She stayed on in Ayodhya
  • She went back to the forest
  • She went into the earth
  • She went to heaven
Read the whole story — The last assembly

Rama told Valmiki that Sita should come to the assembly and swear, and then he would take her back.

Valmiki stood up himself and said Sita was innocent, and that his word should be enough. Rama said he believed it too, but that it had to be shown to the people.

Sita came, stood looking at the ground, and said that if she had known no one but Rama in thought, word and deed, then let mother earth take her in.

The earth opened, the goddess of the earth rose with a throne, took Sita in her lap, and went down. The assembly was left watching.

Who am I?

Lanka was mine first. My own half-brother took it from me, and I had to go north and settle there. Who am I?

  • Kubera
  • Vibhishana
  • Maya
  • Sumali
Read the whole story — Whose Lanka it was

Lanka was originally a city built by Vishvakarma, and it belonged to the demons. In fear of Vishnu the demons went down to Patala and the city stood empty.

Then Brahma gave it to his descendant Kubera. Kubera settled there and came to be the lord of wealth.

Ravana was his half-brother. After winning his boon by penance he challenged Kubera, beat him in battle, and took Lanka. The Pushpaka came to him in that same defeat.

Kubera went north and founded Alakapuri. So the flying chariot Rama returned to Ayodhya in was in fact Kubera's — and after the war Vibhishana gave it to Rama.

Why is that?

Grown up, Hanuman had forgotten his real strength. Why?

  • Because the sages had cursed him to remember it only when reminded
  • Because he had been injured
  • Because he had asked for it as a boon himself
  • Because Indra had taken his strength away
Read the whole story — Taking the sun for a fruit

The infant Hanuman took the rising sun for a ripe fruit and leapt into the sky to catch it.

Indra struck him with the thunderbolt. Hanuman fell and his jaw was broken — "hanu" means jaw, and that is where the name came from.

The wind god was angry and stopped the air of the world. The gods had to appease him, and each gave the child a boon.

But the child was so mischievous that the sages could not live in peace. So they laid a light curse on him — you will forget your strength, and remember it only when someone reminds you.

That is why, at the end of the Kishkindha Kanda, Jambavan has to count out Hanuman's powers to him one by one.

What happened?

What did Rama do after what was said in the city?

  • He punished the washerman
  • He sent Sita, who was pregnant, to the forest
  • He called an assembly and defended himself
  • He gave up the kingdom
Read the whole story — Lakshmana's hardest day

Rama called all four brothers, told them, and gave Lakshmana the task.

Sita was told she was being taken to visit the sages' hermitages. She was glad — she even packed gifts for the sages' wives.

After they crossed the Ganga, Lakshmana told her the truth and then broke down. Sita fainted.

When she came round she told Lakshmana she was not carrying any complaint against Rama, and to give him this message: that he was doing a king's duty. Then Lakshmana went back.

Valmiki or tradition?

What do many modern scholars hold about the Uttara Kanda?

  • That it is the oldest part of the Ramayana
  • That Valmiki wrote it first
  • That it is really part of the Mahabharata
  • That it may be a later layer
Read the whole story — What the argument is about

The five middle kandas — Ayodhya through Yuddha — run consistently in style. The Bala Kanda and the Uttara Kanda have long been argued over.

The arguments are several: differences in language, the shape of the narrative, and the fact that the story comes to a natural close at the end of the Yuddha Kanda.

On the other side, a good deal is left unfinished without the Uttara Kanda — Ravana's background, Hanuman's childhood, and Sita's ending.

We have kept it because it is part of the tradition, and marked it because a reader should know the debate exists. That is this site's method — not to hide, but to say.

Fact

What was placed beside Rama at the horse sacrifice, since he had not married again?

  • A golden image of Sita
  • A painting of Sita
  • The sandals
  • The chudamani
Read the whole story — A Sita of gold

Sita was in the forest, and the sacrifice was being held in Ayodhya.

Rama did not marry again. He had a golden image of Sita made, and the rite was performed with it.

The text puts the image in Rama's own words — it was his decision, not anyone's advice.

It is the hardest irony in the Uttara Kanda — the one who had been sent away from the assembly was the one without whom the rite could not be completed.

Who said it?

"I have known no one but Rama — if that is true, let mother earth take me into herself." Who said this?

  • Kausalya
  • Mandodari
  • Sita
  • Tara
Read the whole story — Refusing to return

The most important thing about this scene is that Sita does not refuse to swear — she refuses to return.

Rama had said he would take her back after the oath. Sita took the oath, and turned that same oath into her way out.

Valmiki writes that the sages, kings and citizens in the assembly were all struck dumb. So was Rama.

It is the one moment in the Ramayana where Rama cannot stop something.

Put it in order

Which is the right order of these events?

  • Lava and Kusha singing → Sita's exile → the horse sacrifice → Sita going into the earth
  • Sita's exile → the horse sacrifice → Sita going into the earth → Lava and Kusha singing
  • The horse sacrifice → Sita's exile → Lava and Kusha singing → Sita going into the earth
  • Sita's exile → the horse sacrifice → Lava and Kusha singing → Sita going into the earth
Read the whole story — The story comes back to itself

The Uttara Kanda is built as a circle. A story that began with a king having no sons ends with that same king's sons singing his story to him.

Everything in between — the exile, the abduction, the war — has by now become a song, sung by two boys on a vina.

And the woman the song is about is sitting in the assembly, listening to it.

The Ramayana ends by telling its own story back to itself.