The Unanswered Riddle, the Ascetic's End — Vikram and Baital, illustration

Chapter 12

The Unanswered Riddle, the Ascetic's End

Vikram could not find the answer to the last tale's riddle, and just then the vetala told him the ascetic Shantshil's real plot — how did the night in the cremation ground end?

The Unanswered Riddle, the Ascetic's End is chapter 12 of Vikram and Baital. Source: Baital Pachisi, tale 25 and the ending. It is told in 2 scenes — The twenty-fifth tale: two princesses, two kings; The vetala's warning — followed by 10 quiz questions.

The twenty-fifth tale: two princesses, two kings

Vikram took the vetala down from the tree again, set him on his shoulder and walked on. 'Now hear the twenty-fifth and last tale, King,' said the vetala.

In the south there stood a city called Dharmpur, ruled by King Mahabal. One day a rival king of that same country marched against his capital and laid siege to it. After several days of fighting, part of Mahabal's army went over to the enemy and many of the rest were cut down. With the city lost, he slipped away by night with his queen and daughter and fled into the forest. After many kos of walking, day broke and a village came into view. The king seated the queen and the princess under a tree and went toward the village to find something to eat. Meanwhile a band of men surrounded him and ordered him to lay down his arms. The king shot arrows at them and they shot back, and the fight lasted three hours. At last an arrow struck the king's forehead and he died on the spot.

The queen and the princess saw the king dead and went back weeping into the forest. After many kos they grew tired, sat down and sank into anxious thoughts. Just then King Chandrasen, hunting with his son, came into the same forest. He noticed two sets of footprints and said to his son, 'How can human footprints have come here, in this deep forest?' The son said, 'Maharaj, these are women's footprints. A man's foot is not so small.' 'True,' said the king. 'No man has feet so delicate.' The son said, 'They have only just passed this way.' The king said, 'Come, let us look for them in the forest. If we find them, I will give you the one with the larger foot and take the small-footed one myself.' With this agreement they went on and found the two sitting. They seated them on their horses and took them home. As they had agreed, the son took the queen and the king took the princess.

When he had finished the tale, the vetala asked, 'King, tell me: what will be the relationship between the children of these two?' The king said nothing, for he could not find the answer.

The vetala's warning

Then the vetala said gladly, 'King, your patience and courage have greatly pleased me. I will tell you something now; listen carefully. A man whose body hair is like thorns and whose body is like wood, whose name is Shantshil, has come to your city. It is he who sent you to fetch me. He himself sits in the cremation ground performing his rite, and he means to kill you. So I warn you now: when his worship is done, he will say to you, "King, prostrate yourself so that all eight limbs of your body touch the ground." You must answer, "I am a king of kings, and every ruler bows to me. To this day I have bowed to no one and I do not know how. You are a teacher; show me how it is done, and then I will do it." When he bends down, strike him with your sword so that his head is cut off. Then you will reign without interruption. If you do not, he will kill you and reign himself.'

Having warned the king in these words, the vetala left the corpse and went on his way. With some of the night still remaining, the king carried the corpse to the ascetic and set it before him. The ascetic was glad to see it and praised the king warmly. Then he recited his spells and brought the corpse to life, made a fire offering, sat facing south and offered to his god all the materials he had prepared: betel, flowers, incense, lamps and sacred food. Then he said to the king, 'Bow down. Great honour will be yours, and the eight supernatural powers will always dwell in your house.'

The king remembered the vetala's words. He folded his hands and said humbly, 'Maharaj, I do not know how to bow. But you are a teacher; if you will kindly show me, I will do it.' At this the ascetic bent his head to prostrate himself, and in that instant the king struck him with his sword. The ascetic fell where he stood, and the vetala came and showered flowers on the king. It is said that there is no wrong in killing one who would himself have killed another.

Then Indra and the gods, who had seen the king's courage, came in their chariots and raised shouts of victory. Indra said gladly, 'Ask a boon.' The king folded his hands and said, 'Maharaj, let this story of mine become famous in the world.' Indra said, 'As long as the moon, the sun, the earth and the sky endure, this story will be famous, and you will rule over the whole earth.'

With these words Indra returned to his heaven, and the king threw the two corpses into a cauldron of oil. Two heroes appeared and said, 'What are your commands?' The king said, 'Come when I call you to mind.' Having taken their promise, the king returned home and took up the work of government.

Note: This chapter is written from tale 25 and the ending of the popular Hindi tradition of the Baital Pachisi (Lallu Lal's text, in John Platts' 1871 English translation). In the text the riddle of the twenty-fifth tale is not answered; here too it is not. King Mahabal's death is in the text as an arrow wound and beheading in a battle; here it is told with restraint and briefly. The identity of the two corpses and the two heroes at the end is not clear in the text, so here too only as much is said as the text says. Names are as in the text: Mahabal, Chandrasen, Shantshil.

Source: Baital Pachisi — Lallu Lal's Hindi Baital Pachisi (1805), in the text rendered by Duncan Forbes, The Unanswered Riddle, the Ascetic's End

Now — how much stayed with you?

Fact

In the twenty-fifth tale, why did King Mahabal go into the forest at night?

  • He had gone out hunting
  • He wanted to practise austerity
  • Another king had besieged his capital and his army was cut down, so he fled with his queen and daughter
  • He went on an ascetic's command
Read the whole story — A besieged city

Mahabal was king of Dharmpur.

His queen and daughter were with him.

What happened?

What happened to the queen and princess in the forest?

  • The king went toward a village for food and was killed there; mother and daughter went back weeping into the forest and sat down
  • They reached the village
  • They drowned in a river
  • They lost the king, then found him again
Read the whole story — Under a tree

The king had seated them and gone to bring something to eat.

He did not return.

What happened?

How did King Chandrasen and his son find the two, and what did they agree?

  • By sending an army
  • With hunting dogs
  • On an ascetic's word
  • They saw footprints; they agreed that the one with the larger foot the son would keep, and the one with the small foot the king
Read the whole story — Small and large feet

The son said a man's foot is not so small.

The two had come out hunting.

Riddle

The vetala asked what relationship the two's children would have. What did Vikram do?

  • Said they would be brother and sister
  • Fell silent, because the answer did not come to him
  • Said they would be enemies
  • Scolded the vetala into silence
Read the whole story — Silent for the first time

The last riddle of the Baital Pachisi, to which Vikram had no answer.

Just then the vetala told him the real matter.

What happened?

What did the vetala, pleased, tell Vikram?

  • That the ascetic Shantshil wanted to kill him, and when the worship was finished would ask him to prostrate himself
  • That Bhartrihari was about to return
  • That his throne was in danger
  • That the king's brother was his enemy
Read the whole story — The last secret

The vetala said, I am pleased by your patience.

The ascetic was at his rite in the cremation ground.

Who said it?

'You are a teacher, show me how, and then I will do it.' Who said this to whom?

  • Shantshil to Vikram
  • The vetala to Shantshil
  • Vikram to the vetala
  • Vikram to Shantshil, by the trick the vetala taught
Read the whole story — A taught line

It was said when the ascetic said, 'let all eight limbs touch the ground.'

The vetala had told him beforehand to say it.

What happened?

When the ascetic bent to learn how to bow, what happened?

  • The king forgave him
  • The king struck with his sword and the ascetic fell on the spot
  • The ascetic vanished
  • The vetala seized the ascetic
Read the whole story — One blow

The vetala stood nearby.

He showered flowers.

What happened?

When Indra told him to ask a boon, what did Vikram ask?

  • Immortality
  • Rule of the whole earth
  • That this story of his become famous in the world
  • All of Shantshil's jewels
Read the whole story — His own story

Indra said, as long as the moon and sun endure, this tale will last.

Indra also called him ruler of the earth.

What happened?

At the end of the tale, what did the king do with the two corpses, and what happened?

  • Cast them into the Ganga
  • Buried them under the ascetic's seat
  • Burnt them on the spot
  • Threw them in the cauldron of oil, and two heroes appeared, from whom the king took a promise to come when he remembered them
Read the whole story — Two heroes

The king said, when I remember you.

Then he returned home and took up the work of government.

Interpretation

How is it fair to read this ending, in our reading?

  • The greatest danger was the ascetic, but the one who told of it was the very vetala the king was carrying on his shoulder; perhaps the patience of twenty-five tales was for this trust
  • The king took revenge on the ascetic because he was Bhartrihari's enemy
  • The vetala deceived the king
  • The ascetic was the real king
Read the whole story — A reading

The vetala saw Vikram's patience and told him the secret.

This is a present-day reader's reading, not a claim made by the text itself.

Questions about The Unanswered Riddle, the Ascetic's End

What happens in The Unanswered Riddle, the Ascetic's End (Vikram and Baital)?

Vikram could not find the answer to the last tale's riddle, and just then the vetala told him the ascetic Shantshil's real plot — how did the night in the cremation ground end? The story moves through: The twenty-fifth tale: two princesses, two kings; The vetala's warning.

What comes after The Unanswered Riddle, the Ascetic's End in Vikram and Baital?

The Unanswered Riddle, the Ascetic's End is the last chapter of Vikram and Baital.

What is the source for The Unanswered Riddle, the Ascetic's End?

Baital Pachisi, tale 25 and the ending.